Sorry Kimball family, but you willingly provided a really good topic for discussion and, not surprisingly, I have an opinion. I think this is something people will want to think about and discuss.
I just finished watching the premiere episode of Family Armor. I had watched only a portion and put it aside until a friend's husband said on Facebook,
"Caught five minutes of it but turned it off when I saw the sicko
owner/father had a video camera in his "live in daughter's" bedroom to
"keep an eye on her". Way to teach trust, control freak. Poor
representation of Mormons if you ask me."
I hadn't got that far and my thought was, Carp. Didn't I tell people to tune in to see what Mormons were like? I'll have to comment on this. I'm sure my non-Mormon friends will know that I would not agree with this tactic but silence is ambiguous.
So, I finished the episode and to Trent's credit, that's not exactly what he said. The point he made was logical, I'll give him that. He basically said that the cameras he put throughout the house were a reminder that wherever you go, even when you think you're alone, Heavenly Father is watching you.
However, this portrayal of Heavenly Father was a little bit too 1984 for my liking. (I casually mentioned this to my Stake President yesterday at our ward conference and he immediately said while grimmacing, "Ooh, that sounds like Big Brother." Uh huh.) It's true that in some way Heavenly Father is always keeping tabs on us. But does that make surveillance of your family proper and right?
The Kimball's 16-year-old niece Jessica was brought to the Kimball's home because she was skipping high school classes, partying with her friends, and maybe for other reasons that were not divulged to protect her privacy and reputation. There might very well be things that we don't know that could make it understandable how her father could say that as much as he wants her to come home, he would leave her in Texas the rest of her life if he had to.
Unfortunately, the way this was edited, it looks like a girl was sent away from her family and was not allowed to even talk to them on the phone for six months because she was skipping classes and partying with her friends. It's probably not what Jude and I would do but she was told repeatedly that this would happen if she kept it up and she kept it up. So, the way I see it, she chose this for herself. And I agree with Trent that she needs to get love and self-esteem from home and family, not from boys. But not talking with her family for six months? That's not something Jude and I would ever do. When does Heavenly Father say that we're not allowed to pray to him?
Once she was contrite and wanted to be with her family, she was not allowed. Trent doesn't think she's ready to go home because... she accidentally damaged a hidden water main with a golf cart? A teenage girl wants to be with her family and said she was ready to follow the rules of the house. I'd call that success, wouldn't you?
As I see it, the Kimballs and Jessica's parents risk her transitioning from contrite to just outright pissed off. And if she gets to that stage, what exactly is stopping her from taking off? I left home at 15, for good. (In a totally reverse scenario where I was the responsible one and my parents were the irresponsible ones, but self-sufficiency is my point.)
The only acceptable reason I can think of for kicking a child out of your home is if they are endangering themselves through drugs, or by some other drastic behaviour like anorexia or cutting, or if they are endangering other family members. And of course in these instances you'd get them professional help. Or, if they've dropped out of high school and refuse to get a job and pay you rent.
The teenage years are a transition for parents as much as kids. They are just a few short years away from having the freedom to make all the choices they want, no matter what their parents say or think. To use those years trying to force behaviour is a waste of precious time.
It seems like some Mormons think that the worst thing we can ever do is sin and their job is to prevent their kids from sinning, almost at all cost. If they can raise children who are as obedient to gospel principles as possible they've done their job.
But what if your kid is only obedient out of fear? What if your kid is only obedient because they don't want to disappoint you or they don't want to disappoint God? Do you call that a success? NO!
To compel your children to rightness is to act like Satan did in the preexistence. It's LDS belief that there was a council before we came to earth and in that council Satan offered to be the saviour of mankind and somehow he would compel us all to choose the right way and not one soul would be lost and the glory would be his. Jehovah offered to be the saviour, to let us choose for ourselves, and the glory would be Heavenly Father's.
I know a family who very much reminds me of what I saw in this Family Armor episode. The dad was even very physically stiff, tense, like Trent appears to be. The mom was more warm, like Courtney, but also had the same beliefs about obedience, discipline, organisation, and rules as Courtney alluded to. Here's what happened: Their first son was always very obedient and good. The mom told me he never broke rules, never acted out. He served a mission for our church. He came home, got married in the temple, then left the church. I think he may have even asked to have his name removed from the record, which is very serious. Their second child went on a mission, then went to school far away and still lives there. Their next child drank and got into trouble in her teens, then got married almost as soon as she was a legal adult. Their next child went through similar teen rebellion and I don't know if she's currently active in the church.
The strict method of parenting works well for little kids but it usually backfires for teens.
When we impose strict obedience and run our families like we run businesses, we teach our children that we don't trust them to choose for themselves. We see our role the same way Satan saw his role. If our kids grow up fine, we can pat ourselves on the back for doing such a good job. If they struggle, we torment ourselves over what we did wrong.
Parents who teach their children to think and act for themselves, to choose the right not because they're afraid of disappointing their parents and their God, but because they see the value in righteousness for its own sake, are parents who know that if their kids are great successes or terrible failures, it's because of their kids and not because of themselves.
It's not the end of of the world, or the end of my daughters' salvation if they make bad choices and get pregnant at 16. I definitely don't feel like it's my job as their parent to use whatever tool or threat I have in my arsenal for "their own good".
I plan to raise my teenagers like Heavenly Father raises me. As Joseph Smith said, "I teach them correct principles and let them govern themselves." Heavenly Father does this. This is what I plan to do, generally speaking. There are usually natural consequences to our actions.
I don't want to shelter my kids from unrighteousness. I don't want to keep them innocent as long as possible. I want to be the one to tell them about all the possibilities in this world, all the potholes, all the evil, while they're still young enough to be more interested in my perspective than the perspective of their friends.
I want to influence their thinking while they're young. Then I want to let them make mistakes and learn from them.
And here's why:
I have faith. I have faith in them that they'll figure things out. I have faith that they can make things right. I have faith in Jesus Christ that he'll make up the difference. I have faith in God's forgiveness and love. I have faith that no matter what happens, it's not the end of the world or the end of their salvation, or the end of their self-worth. EVERYTHING can be made right, even in this life. God can turn the worst situation into something beautiful. He can make strong things weak. He even says that he GAVE us weaknesses so that they can become strengths.
When you put video cameras up to compel kids to make right choices lest they be caught and disciplined, you don't give them room to flex the muscles of their conscience.
Kids need to feel like we have faith in them. They need to feel like we think they're so smart and so good and so capable. If we send them that message not just in what we say but in how we treat them, they will live it.
I don't believe that kids do bad things because their parents don't put up enough safeguards for them. They do bad things because they're not taught otherwise, or when they are taught otherwise, they do bad things because they don't feel love and/or they don't have enough self-confidence and self-love. Self-confidence and self-love is not something we can guarantee, even if we do everything perfectly. But it is something we should always be trying to give in everything we say and do with our kids.
Kicking your kid out of your home might be the best decision because it's all you can do, because you don't have the faculties, the ability to do anything else. But, it's Jude's and my opinion that it's rarely the ideal response.
Take away privileges but don't take away food, shelter and your love. Not talking to your child on the phone for six months because phone privileges have been taken away?!
I'm sure there are exceptions to this rule I just pronounced about kicking out kids. I'm sure there are exceptions to letting our kids make bad decisions and having to live with the consequences. And I definitely believe that families are able to receive revelation from God that is unique to them and I don't know all the details of this situation in the Kimball home. Hey, maybe the teen even chose these consequences for herself! Maybe she was asked what she thought was fitting and in a moment of humble honesty, she agreed this would be best.
Also, I know that 500 hours of footage was whittled down to a 40 minute episode and I'm sure that the producers of this show sought to showcase the Kimballs in this way knowing exactly how it would be perceived, knowing that it would cause controversy.
I also know that there are different ways to reach the same goal and that some are better than others. I had already written this blog post when a talk was given in church on Sunday at our ward conference about this very thing: Obedience. The speaker did a great job explaining that we can do what's right out of fear or out of love. We can do everything right that we're supposed to out of a sense of responsibility and still not be better off than someone who only does half of what they should but does all of it out of pure love for God, themselves, and their fellow man.
The entire episode of Family Armor had the theme of responsibility, discipline and obedience. Even their family motto was something like, "We the Kimball family believe in fulfilling all of our responsibilities." Or maybe that wasn't their family motto, maybe it was just their family theme for the year, influenced in part by Jessica's visit.
Still, it prompted me to ask Jude, "If our family had a motto, what would it be? What do you think it should be?" He said, "We believe in loving God and loving others."
You can't have a better motto than that. Those are the two greatest commandments. If I'm going to get my kids to repeat something until they know it by heart, it's going to be that. I don't care about them finishing their homework or doing their chores as much as I care about them befriending a disabled kid that no one plays with, or helping each other clean their rooms without being asked. I do care about all of it but if there's something I'm going to emphasise over and over, dude-- it's gonna be love.
Trent said, "It's not about Big Love, it's about tough love." That upset my husband, my high priest priesthood holder. He jumped on that and said, "No, it's not. It's about love." Just love.
With all due respect, that's what Jude and got out of the episode and that's what we get out of Mormonism.
Daily Gratitudes
- I love my bishop and stake president. They have a very warm, loving, genuine air about them. My bishop had no reason to come up to me and say, "You have cute children. You really make very cute children. I'm not just saying that to be polite. You really do have cute children." He was very sweet about it. I love it when people dole out compliments unexpectedly like that.
- Jude has gotten so much better at listening and not trying to give advice.
- It's cold but still no snow.
- Um... Modern plumbing and electricity.
- Food.
Recent Comments