Vince sent me this article from Times & Seasons on Spiritual Pickpockets to read and asked me to tell him what I think. Actually, he asked me what I "reckon". He likes that word. :-) I had enough thoughts about it that I decided to make a blog post out of it. (And I've got at least six hours of sleep under my belt this time, so hopefully I won't muddle this too much.)
The article discusses the trend in some branches of Christianity to preach Prosperity Theology, citing Gloria Copeland as saying, "God knows where the money is, and he knows how to get the money to you.”
Kenneth and Gloria Copeland make me want to puke. Wait-- I need to stop being so subtle and try harder to say exactly what I mean. I think Kenneth and Gloria Copeland spoon-feed Satan his porridge when they're not busy scamming people. They are skeevy and evil. I'm not saying they know they are evil. They might be just lulled and deceived.
But wait-- what about The Mormons? Don't they celebrate wealth too and use each other for a dizzying rotation of MLM schemes? Well, that's what the article discusses. (There's a difference, however, between what individual members do and what the church teaches.)
And I'd like to point out that this is not a "Mormon" thing. Again, this mindset is more prevalent in the Utah area. I am rarely approached to be a part of any MLM company and I'm exactly the kind of person you'd want in your downline. And I have never heard anyone at church cite wealth as a blessing from paying tithing. I have heard people express gratitude for their basic needs being met when it was a leap of faith to pay tithing. I suspect most people in our ward credit their well-chosen professional careers for their wealth. (The number of professionals in our ward is insane. I've never seen anything like it. We could open our own town and be self-sufficent! ;-)
The writer of the article asks, "When was the last time you heard Malachi quoted?"
Prove me now herewith, saith the LORD of hosts, if I will not open you the windows of heaven, and pour you out a blessing, that there shall not be room enough to receive it.
Um, years? Months? I don't know. But I've never heard it asserted that this scripture refers to financial blessings. It could refer to babies, health, friends, all manners of blessings.
The writer says,
"I dispute the notion that God grants such wealth, or that He removes it or prevents one from obtaining it.
Such a belief, even if privately held, is insidious. It destroys community and eliminates any hope of Zion, resulting in subtle judgements about the worthiness and standing of other members or visitors based on their dress, their car, their home or apartment. Good luck with that Zion concept.
I’m simply not interested in worshiping a God that capriciously grants wealth and comfort to a select few, while allowing pious and worthy people from all over to suffer and die in poverty."
Mmm... the scriptures are rife with stories of God taking away blessings and granting blessings. Job? He does this when there's unrighteous dominion and he does this for no apparent reason.
We're also told to ask and we shall receive. We're told that whatsoever thing we ask, having faith in Christ, if it be God's will, we shall receive it. We're told in Jacob 2:19:
"And after ye have obtained a hope in Christ ye shall obtain riches, if ye seek them; and ye will seek them for the intent to do good-- to clothe the naked, and to feed the hungry, and to liberate the captive, and administer relief to the sick and the afflicted."
Yes, the Lord blesses people with money. The prophet, apostles, mission presidents all need to be self-sufficient to receive those callings. They don't need to be rich but they need to be well enough off that they can retire and devote an indefinite number of years (or the rest of their lives, as is the case for apostles and prophets) to the church. Because they don't get paid by the church.
Does this writer really mean to suggest that the Lord didn't bless these people with money? These men who were foreordained to these callings?
Such a belief does NOT result in judgements of other members by necessity. How we judge each other is a choice. It has never, ever occurred to me that people who are less fortunate than I am are so because they're less righteous. That's absurd. I doubt this is a prevalent notion.
It's my opinion that this writer has difficulty viewing the plan of salvation outside extremes. Either God is capricious or he's nonchalant and standoffish.
Overall, the Lord's plan is to let us be, yes. He gave us free will. And in that sense he does "step back". But this concept, while interesting (and thanks for sharing, Rory) is not Mormonism:
"My concept of God, my personal theology, is that he loves us, but he is distant. He gives us room, and he knows/trusts/hopes that we will do that which furthers his plan. Sometimes we won’t. Sometimes things get ugly. But his plan is such that, on the whole and collectively, we step forward more than we step back, and in the process he grows and learns with us and through us."
God is intimately involved in the church which "furthers His plan" and he is intimately involved in our lives. "He grows and learns with us and through us"? Mmmm... I'd like to see one scripture that even remotely suggests that God needs us for his growth and learning. Then contrast those with scriptures about how he's omniscient and omnipotent.
Sheesh. I mean, I am far from a scriptorian. I don't know my scriptures well at all and still I have all sorts of scriptures coming to mind that refute a lot of what this writer asserts. Only laziness prevents them from citing them. Basically, a lot of ask and ye shall receive and a lot of stuff about faith.
God can answer prayers everyday about the smallest things if we have faith and if we ask. I've seen it in my life. I've seen it in the lives of others.
What seems to be bothering this writer, and Sydney (a new blog commenter), and lots of other people is why some people suffer while other people seem to be so blessed? There seems to be no rhyme or reason. The reason for that is because there is no set pattern, there are no consistent direct correlations:
Bad childhood ≠ happy adulthood
Happy childhood ≠ struggles in adulthood
Impatient people ≠ get infertility
Pay tithing ≠ get wealth
Example ≠ example
ANY time we try to get inside the head of God, we are being prideful or we're lacking faith or just wasting our time. We take a few circumstances and try to interpret them. When God makes decisions about the blessings he grants or withholds he considers our pre-existent natures before we came to Earth, our families, our friends, our upbringings, the media to which we've been exposed, our health, the food we eat, the people around us and how they will be affected by our circumstances, what goals we have for our futures, what goals he has for our futures, what our future kids and grand kids will need by way of experiences and help, and on and on and when all these major considerations plus the incidentals are combined, he has situations that are as unique as our DNA. Even when you pit against each other two families who seem to have identical situations, you're so far from the truth that you might as well be a zygote.
So, it's stupid to try to second-guess the will of God and it's childish to conclude, simply because you don't understand God's plan, that he's not intimately involved with a plan. Just because you don't understand the rules doesn't mean there isn't a game.
As for wealth, it's not always a blessing. Stingy people will be stingy with or without wealth and generous people will be generous with or without wealth; they'll just find different ways to be stingy or generous. So, some people are given money to be a blessing to others and some people are given money to highlight their character. Having money is not always a blessing for people! And being poor is not always a curse.
There can be so many reasons for why God would want my life to be the way it is and yours to be the way yours is and for Leona Helmsley (or whatever the name is of that rich woman whom everyone hated) to have the life she had.
If God tried to teach us all through the same circumstances and if 1 + 1 always equaled 2, then we'd stop living by faith and we'd be constantly motivated by rewards because we'd have figured out the pattern and the rules of the game and your decisions would most often be identical to mine because we all like rewards, and then our world would be totally boring and everyone would be rich and we wouldn't learn as much.
Both the intervention of God and the lack of intervention by God are ways in which God is intimately involved in our lives. There are reasons for everything and we need to have enough faith to stop being preoccupied with the reasons. They always come in good time.
That's about all I have to say about that. This was probably a carpy, disorganised blog post. Sorry. I just don't have time to fuss over it. I'm not even re-reading what I've written, which will probably bite me in the butt, and you'll say in comments, "I think you were wrong when you said this." and I'll be all, "SIGHHHH. Not what I meant." and you'll be all, "Well, then maybe you should proofread then", and I'll be all manifesto-like, "Ya, I'm going to proofread everything I write at least three times from now until eternity!" And then I won't. And then we'll repeat this conversation.
;-p
Daily Gratitudes
- Jude and I had some nice moments alone this morning listening to some ironic and satirical songs I downloaded.
- My hips didn't hurt so much today after walking the dog as they did on Sunday.
- Katie sent me the loveliest email. She's such a blessing and has taught me so much. I love her guts.
- Veronica agreed to watch the kids for the day and I know they will love her and she'll be so enthusiastic. I love her energy.
- Jude is not stressed about having to make all the meals while I'm gone. I feel bad about it. I wanted to make and freeze stuff but neither of us could think of anything I could make that the kids would eat.
NOT Daily Gratitude
- Speaking of God and curses, I just got my period. A week early. Right before my trip to London. God is definitely NOT a woman.



Recent Comments